> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.gottabekidding.me/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Three Stars Grew Big Enough to Eat Their Planets. The Planets Are Still There.
- URL: https://www.gottabekidding.me/three-stars-grew-big-enough-to-eat-their-planets-the-planets-are-still-there/
- Published: 2026-11-17T11:03:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T11:03:00.000Z
- Description: One survivor might be luck. Three suggest these worlds share a trick for outlasting a swelling star, and no one has worked out what it is.
- Author: Parallax
- Tags: Astronomy

A planet resembling Jupiter circles the star 24 Bootis on a path tighter than Mercury's orbit around our sun. At its largest, that star grew over 100 times wider than the sun, well beyond where the planet orbits. The planet should be gone. It isn't.

Aging stars like the sun eventually swell into red giants. Close planets get engulfed or dragged in by gravity. Astronomers long assumed tightly orbiting planets could not survive. A U.S.-led group reported the lone exception, around a Little Dipper star, in 2023.

Astronomers led by Qian Shengbang of Yunnan University found three more using NASA's TESS telescope. They targeted stars past their peak, ones that had ballooned and then contracted, spotted through faint flickers caused by vibrations deep inside. A planet beside such a star has plainly made it through.

Three qualified: 24 Bootis, HD 12648 and TYC 4282-605-1, each with a heavy planet on a close orbit. Six sets of computer models agreed each star once stretched past its planet. Qian said one survivor could be luck, but three suggest some shared physics at work.

The researchers called the survival a mystery. Perhaps each star tangled with a companion and never reached its expected size. Or perhaps the stars swallowed planets orbiting even closer, jostling the survivors into new paths. Neither idea has been tested.

The sun should become a red giant roughly 5 billion years from now, and standard theory says Earth is probably doomed to be swallowed. Qian said the solar system's fate may be less tidy than predicted.

Even a lucky Earth would be a sterile, scorched cinder by then. Escaping the sun's appetite is one thing; the retirement plan still needs work.

**Read the full story at** [South China Morning Post, October 28, 2026](https://www.scmp.com/news/china/science/article/3372402/chinese-astronomers-find-planets-somehow-avoided-death-red-giant-stars?ref=gottabekidding.me)

---

**Hot Take:** One man on Monty Python's plague cart insisted he wasn't dead yet and got clobbered anyway. Three planets saying it at once are much harder to clobber.